Race, class, and goldfish: how a homemade footpath aquarium divided New York
By Jake Offenhartz
New York: A couple of longtime Brooklyn residents were lounging in the heat last week, staring at a footpath tree pit often flooded by a leaky fire hydrant, when they came up with the idea for a makeshift aquarium.
“We started joking about: what if we added fish,” recalled Hajj-Malik Lovick, 47, a lifelong resident of the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighbourhood. “Since the water is always there sitting in the puddle, why not turn this into something that’s more interesting?”
Fish swim in a pool of water next to a fire hydrant in the Brooklyn borough of New York.Credit: AP
After fortifying the edges of the tree bed with rocks and brick, they bought 100 common goldfish from a pet store for $US16 and dumped them in.
The appearance of peanut-sized fish swimming around the shallow basin quickly became a neighbourhood curiosity, drawing visitors who dubbed it “the Hancock Street Bed-Stuy Aquarium”.
But as videos and news stories about the fish pit have circulated online, the project has drawn concern from city officials and backlash from animal rights advocates. In the early hours of Wednesday morning, two neighbourhood residents, Emily Campbell and Max David, carried out a rescue mission. Using nets and plastic bags, they pulled about 30 fish from the 5 centimentre deep waters.
They say they were rescuing the fish from inhumane conditions. But the operation has sparked a roiling debate about gentrification in the historically black neighbourhood, which has seen an influx of young white residents in recent years.
Georgia Ramirez Wright stops riding her bike to take a photo of goldfish swimming in a tree pit filled with water pooling from a leaking fire hydrant.Credit: AP
“I’m very aware of the optics of a white yuppie coming here and telling this man who’s lived in the neighbourhood his whole life that he doesn’t know what he’s doing,” said Campbell, a self-described fish enthusiast who previously worked in aquaponics. “I do symp with that. I just don’t want to watch 40 fish suffocate in a puddle from their own waste.”
Campbell, 29, said she was working to rehome the rescued fish, keeping many of them in tanks inside her apartment. Several people had contacted her with concerns about the remaining fish inside the pit. “I’m still concerned for the fishes’ well-being, but I’m more concerned about the divisiveness in the community,” she said on Friday.
Those involved in the footpath experiment say they have enriched the neighbourhood and provided a better life for the goldfish, a small breed that is usually sold as food for larger marine species. They feed the fish three times per day and take shifts watching over them, ensuring the fire hydrant remains at a slow trickle.
“I feel like we’re helping the goldfish,” Lovick said. “These people came here and just want to change things.”
In recent days, supporters have come by to donate decorations, such as pearls and seashells, as well as food, according to Floyd Washington, one of the pond monitors.
A sign is posted near to a pool of water with fish swimming inside in the Brooklyn borough of New York.Credit: AP
“It brings conversation in the community,” he said. “People stop on the way to work and get to see something serene and meet their neighbours. Now we have these fish in common.”
He said the group planned to keep the fish in place for about two more weeks, then donate them to neighbourhood children. On Friday afternoon, the visitors included local grocery workers, an actor, and a wide-eyed toddler whose nanny had learned about the tank on the news.
“It’s a really beautiful guerilla intervention,” said Josh Draper, an architect who keeps his own goldfish in his Bed-Stuy apartment. “It’s creating a city that’s alive.”
Another passerby suggested the fish would soon become “rat food”.
“Nah,” replied Washington. “That’s Eric Adams right there,” he said, pointing to one of the few black fish, apparently named after the city’s current mayor. “No one messes with him.”
Adams did not respond to a request for comment.
But a spokesperson for the city’s Department of Environmental Protection said there were real safety concerns about leaking hydrants. They had sent crews to fix the hydrant multiple times, but it had been turned back on by residents.
“We love goldfish also, but we know there is a better home for them than on a footpath,” said an agency spokesperson, Beth DeFalco.
As of Friday afternoon, dozens of fish were still swimming in the pit.
AP
Get a note directly from our foreign correspondents on what’s making headlines around the world. Sign up for the weekly What in the World newsletter here.